 Enhance your Writing Skills |
 Handigifts |
 Become a Photographer |
 Learn about Jazz & More |
 Love the Art |
Anti-Heroes in Film and
Literature
It was Aristotle who first described the
elements of a tragic hero in the classical Greek tragedy
plays of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides 2500 years
ago.
Then, Shakespeare created his own type of
tragedy plays, with their own distinct tragic heroes - Hamlet,
Macbeth, Othello, King Lear. They had similar principles which
Aristotle first outlined.
There's a new kind of hero in town - the
anti-hero. We're not sure when the anti-hero
came about; its definition depends on the relative time
period.
Defining the
Anti-Hero
|
Character: Dexter
Morgan Novel(s): Darkly Dreaming Dexter series by Jeff Lindsay Dexter is one of my favourite antiheroes. He's a forensic blood splatter analyst for the Miami Police Department, but by night he's a serial killer who murders criminals or other immoral people. These novels have been turned into a TV series. When he was 3, he watched his mother's murder and since then has been numb to violence. He is driven to kill by an inner voice whom he calls "The Dark Passenger". |
|
Character: Roland
Deschain Novel(s): The Dark Tower series by Stephen King Roland Deschain of Gilead comes from a long line of gunslingers and belongs to a knightly order. These series of books were inspired by the poem "Childe Roland to the Dark Tower Came" by Robert Browning. The character is a resemblance of a character in a Clint Eastwood western. Roland's mission is to find the Dark Tower, a building which is said to be the starting point of all universes. |
|
Character: Stephen
Dedalus Novel(s): A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce This novel is a semi-autobiographical account of the author James Joyce. Stephen Dedalus represents Joyce's alter ego. He is also an important character in Joyce's other novel, Ulysses. Stephen is originally a sensitive, thoughtful boy. As he grows up, he struggles with nationality, religion, morality and his family. He decides to reject all these social bonds and live freely as an artist instead. He transitions from an innocent sheltered boy to an independent individual. "A man of genius makes no mistakes. His errors are volitional and are the portals of discovery." |
|
Character: Gollum Novel(s): Lord of the Rings series J. R. R. Tolkien Whether or not Gollum can be considered an anti-hero is a matter of opinion. He doesn't really have any redeeming or useful qualities. He's a swamp creature who serves as a warning to those who seek the ring. Gollum is a reminder of what Frodo could end up being. Sometimes he appears as a faithful servant - but ultimately values the ring more than anything else. He is not pure evil like Sauron, though - rather, he is pure weakness. He is the victim of the ring and is destroyed by it. |
|
Character: Jay Gatsby Novel(s): The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald Jay Gatsby is a young man who grew up in poverty. He became famously wealthy through illegal means: organized crime, distributing prohibited alcohol and trading in stolen securities. His re-invention of himself eventually shows that he is a innocent, idealistic young man. His ideals of wealth and of his love, Daisy, are bound to disappoint because they could never live up to his dreams. |
|
Character: Victor
Frankenstein Novel(s): Frankenstein by Mary Shelley Victor is the scientist who creates the Frankenstein creature out of human corpse bits. As a young man, he loved reading about science and creating life. After playing God and creating his monster, however, he is unable to deal with his arrogant endeavors. |
|
Character: Tyler Durden and
the Narrator of the novel Novel(s): Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk This book has been made into a movie. The anonymous narrator is the anti-hero who hates his consumerist life and the state of masculinity in American culture. He creates an underground fighting club. Spoiler Alert: Later we realize that his best friend, Tyler Durden, is a figment of his imagination and Tyler is actually him. |
|
Character: Raoul Duke Novel(s): Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas by Hunter S. Thompson Raoul Duke is the protagonist and anti-hero of the novel. He is a unique individual and an eccentric, hedonistic man. He is almost always in a constant altered state of mind - whether it is from marijuana, cocaine or alcohol. This character was an alter ego of Thompson, who used the character to talk about himself. |
|
Character: V Comic Book: V for Vendetta by Alan Moore and David Lloyd "V" is an anarchist - a freedom fighter and a vigilante who breaks the rules, believing that the "ends justify the means". He lives in a dystopian future that takes place in Britain. He can be considered both the protagonist and antagonist - readers decide whether or not he is a hero fighting for a cause, or if he is simply insane. |
|
Character: Batman Comic Book: Batman by Bob Kane and Bill Finger Batman fights the war on crime using his intellect and technology. His real identity is actually Bruce Wayne, a wealthy philanthropist. These two opposing personalities serve as juxtapositions to each other. He fights crime on his own terms, rather than going about it through the formal legal system. |
There you have it! Do you have any more
examples of anti-heroes?
All time most popular tags
I consider Scott Pilgrim as an anto hero as I've noticed though some readers/viewers may symathise for him due to his seeming somewhat socially inept it isn't to be ignored that he is a very slfish charatcer: he doesn't seem intent on helping any other charatcer in the narrative of the film or comic book than himself and at one point is even unfaithful to his girlfriend
This is an excellent article.
@ash28 - You're right! I can't believe we never brought Robin Hood up! He's probably one of the most classic examples of the anti-hero!
@Yorrick - Wow…yes, people would probably want to identify with Hamlet rather than Dorian Gray. Dorian's downfall was due more to his vanity and I'm not sure what redeemable qualities we could extract from him. Hamlet definitely acted upon motivations outside of his own selfishness.
What other resemblances did you see between Sybil Vane and Ophelia?
I don't know how come all of you have failed to mention Robin Hood as an example!! Doesn't he seem to be a prominent anti hero??
Do you think Gatsby would better fall under the categories of a Byronic hero rather than a tragic hero? Gatsby is living in his own little world; trying to get Daisy back, and turn back the hands of time and act like the past 5 years, since he left Daisy, never happened.
Good point..I think the characteristics of a Byronic hero would definitely apply to Gatsby. This is probably a more modern, romantic interpretation of the tragic hero. The Byronic hero has been said to be a precursor to today's anti-hero, so Gatsby can fall under both categories of the anti-hero and the Byronic hero. Thank you for bringing this up!
Oooh, I loved Wuthering Heights! I would definitely agree that Heathcliff could be an anti-hero. I mean, in essence, he's a bad guy that we can actually sympathize with. He's immoral and full of revenge, yet he does this because of his immortal love for Catherine (if I remember the novel correctly).
Another anti-hero that sticks out in my mind is Leon from the film The Professional, but I guess that's heading out of literature territory. He was a great character, though - I don't know if I would even consider him an anti-hero because he seemed so gentle and kind despite the fact that he was a hitman.
By that rationale , would Heathcliff from Wuthering Heights would be a tragic hero rather than an anti-hero?
I think the notion of an anti-hero is someone whose intentions are good but their means of going about it aren't considered moral or ethical by societal standards, so their downfall could be considered their "means" of doing something. As for a tragic hero, I think they are moral people and their downfall is a slip or failure in their character.
%20342/29x29/cropped/avatar.JPG "Yorrick"){kind=avatar}
I disagree, I think, but it's more likely I'm mixing the two up. An anti-hero can have selfish intentions, such as Gatsby, and their means can be unethical as well. Some anti-heroes are more complex than others, I guess. He penetrated social barriers, yet would his motives make his intentions selfish? For example, he was not fighting racism for the good of mankind.
What about Dorian Gray? That character does not come to mind when I think of the word "heroic" but here it where it gets more complicated. He is an anti-hero I believe.
Is Hamlet not an anti-hero?
This lesson is so interesting!!
Maybe I'm totally off, but I always looked at it as if Tragic heroes go down a straight parabolic path- they go up a bit, then crash down (in terms of plot, they start off well and eventually end in death or worse). Anti-heroes go through an upside down parabola- first down, then up. So tragic heroes and anti heroes are distinct categories. Although of course everything is wide open for interpretations, that's what literature is all about.
I'm not too sure but I think Macbeth is quite an anti-hero.
His redeeming qualities are shown only at the beginning through the reports of others and in the end when he valiantly takes of Macduff even when he knows the witches have betrayed him.
So are Hamlet and Othello.
Right! Actually I was going to include Holden Caulfield, but for some reason I forgot about him. I will add him later :)
I think you analyze Gollum on a deeper perspective, he does serve as a warning as the consequences for what can happen (although he doesn't warn people outright). I'll take a look at Heart of Darkness. Yossarian from Catch-22 is actually a good one too. I tried to avoid Shakespeare in this lesson, but maybe I should make mention of them. Possible candidates include Macbeth, Shylock, Hamlet and Iago - but they could also be considered tragic heroes as well. I'm not really sure how to distinguish the more modern tragic hero with the anti-hero. Or maybe there are the same thing?
Great lesson, all excellent examples.
As for more examples, if I say Holden Caulfield, are you guys gonna go "not again" and come all the way here to beat me up? If not, then I wanna say Holden Caulfield :)
Also Col Kurtz from Conrad's Heart of Darkness is a very intriguing character. Some may think of him as an outright villain, but he's not that black and white. The protagonist of the book has grey shades too.
Btw, isn't there room for a Shakespearean character here?
Interesting! Anti heroes are a lot more fun than regular ones. They just have a contrast that makes them more real.
I don't really think Gollum was a swamp creatue that warned people of seeking the ring… and I didn't remember Gatsby achieving his wealth through illegal means (even though I read that book a long time ago, maybe I forgot that point). The other ones are pretty well done though. I'm a big fan of V and Batman!
Now I feel like reading Fight Club… by the way, you should warn people of that spoiler.
Good lesson though.
Anyone who stops learning is old, whether twenty or eighty. Anyone who keeps learning stays young. The greatest thing in life is to keep your mind young.
© 2008–2012 Savvica, Inc. View Our Service Agreement and Privacy Policy . Are you a college recruiter? See our Recruiting Services!
Are you an indian student planning on attending college? Our expert counselling can help.
How does counselling work?
Colleges
Study Abroad
Post Comments